Plebiscite
From Our Foreign Bureaus: Niger Plebiscite, Irish Turnaround, Taiwan Refers a Trade Pact, Chavez Scheming
California's meltdown has been so all-consuming that it's been awhile since this blog checked in on direct democratic goings-on overseas. So here goes.
IRISH VIEWS SHIFT ON LISBON: The Irish voted down the Lisbon Treaty -- the de facto new constitution for the European Union last year. Now a new poll -- in advance of a likely fall vote on the treaty -- shows growing support in Ireland for the treaty. What's changed? The country's once-strong economy has collapsed.
TAIWANESE REFERENDUM ON CHINA TRADE PACT: The pro-independence opposition in Taiwan announced it would collect signatures for a referendum on a new trade pact signed by the government with China.
NIGER PLEBISCITE: The leader of that African country, a producer of uranium, has dismissed the Parliament and is organizing a referendum on whether to change the constitution to permit him to serve a third term.
Not a Referendum
News organizations around the world -- Reuters, the BBC, the Wall Street Journal -- are reporting that Madagascar's president, who is under pressure to step down, has called for "a referendum."
That's the wrong word.
A referendum is a vote on a legislative action--a law or constitutional amendment. It has true legal force. And referenda occur under constitutional structures (Most of the world's countries and a slim majority of US states have some legal provision for a referendum). In a referendum, voters can decide to block a law or amendment.
What the Madagascar president has called for is an up or down vote on whether he should remain in office. The president himself is putting a vote on the ballot. It's not done through the legislature. And such a vote may not have legal force.
Such a vote -- a measure put directly on the ballot by an executive -- is properly called a plebiscite.And that's what responsible news organizations should call what's going on in Madagascar.
President For Life?
In the most closely watched referendum in the world this month, Venezuelan president Hugo Chavez won a plebiscite he sponsored to eliminate term limits, with 54 percent of the vote. This means he can run again for the presidency in 2012 -- and perhaps hold the office for the rest of his life. The opposition said it would not contest the results.
Chavez and His Plebiscite
Venezuealan president Hugo Chavez has employed direct democracy of a fashion, backing a series of plebiscites to enhance his own power. (His defenders point out that he has allowed himself to lose one of these plebiscites--so there). The latest referendum, scheduled for next month, would lift term limits and allow him to run for re-election. But it's not going well. Chavez, without evidence, is accusing President-Elect Obama of interfering in the vote. The Venezuelan president also wants tear gas used on his opponents, according to this Reuters story.


